Table of Contents
- What Is a 3 Handle Bathtub and Shower Faucet?
- Key Considerations Before Installation
- DIY or Hire a Pro? Installation Difficulty Explained
- Basic Installation Steps
- Better Alternatives to 3 Handle Bathtub and Shower Faucet
- Material and Brand Selection Tips
- Maintenance Tips for Long-Term Use
- Conclusion
- FAQ
Introduction
If every bath is like a game of "guessing the temperature", you are not alone. Many American households still use the old-fashioned 3-handle bathtub and shower faucet, turning it hot, cold, and the middle one for the shower. It seems simple, but in fact, it hides many hidden dangers - unstable water pressure, large fluctuations in water temperature, and troublesome maintenance.
Then, can this kind of system still be used? If one wants to upgrade, is it necessary to break through the wall and reinstall? This article will provide a comprehensive analysis of the installation difficulty, fitting issues and replacement suggestions of 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet, helping you find the best solution between comfort and practicality.
1. What Is a 3 Handle Bathtub and Shower Faucet?
3 handle bathtub and shower faucet is a combination of bathtub and shower faucet system with three control handles, which respectively control the hot and cold water and the water flow mode (faucet or shower head). It is very common in many American families built in the middle of the last century.
However, with the change in household water usage habits, especially as the younger generation prefers simpler and more temperature-controllable methods, this structure seems somewhat outdated. According to the Houzz 2023 report, over 55% of households tend to use single-handle mixing valves or thermostatic systems when renovating their bathrooms.
2. Key Considerations Before Installation
Before planning to replace three handle bathtub and shower faucet, you need to judge from the following three aspects:
- Whether the wall material is easy to drill holes in (professional tools are required for tiles or natural stone);
- Whether the material and layout of the original pipeline are compatible with the new valve body;
- Whether the hole spacing standards are consistent (the center spacing of the three holes is generally 8 inches).
If you plan to retain the three-handle structure and only replace the finish and handle, most mainstream brands have matching trim kits that enable quick replacement.

3. DIY or Hire a Pro? Installation Difficulty Explained
3 handle bathtub and shower faucet installation difficulty mainly depends on whether the spool needs to be replaced or the wall structure changed:
Scenarios suitable for DIY:
- The original system structure is intact and only the appearance accessories need to be replaced.
- The wall surface is a drywall or an easily removable panel.
- Users with a certain foundation in water and electricity.
Recommended scenarios for professional construction:
- The valve core needs to be replaced and the water pipe needs to be modified.
- When installing a constant-temperature or single-handle system, the original holes need to be blocked.
- The wall surface is made of tiles or natural stone, which is difficult to disassemble and assemble.
HomeAdvisor 2023 data shows that the average labor cost for replacing an embedded 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet system is $600, and it can rise to over $1,000 if the water supply needs to be changed.
4. Basic Installation Steps
The standard wall-embedded installation process is as follows:
- Turn off the water source and remove the old parts: including three control handles, decorative cover plates and valve bodies.
- Measure and confirm the specifications of the new system: whether they match the connection positions of the existing pipelines.
- Install a new valve body and reinforce it: Usually, welding or using a PEX hot-melt interface is required.
- Conduct leak-proof tests and sealing treatments;
- Install the decorative panels and handles, and adjust the height and symmetry.
Professional advice: The trajectory adjustment should be precise to avoid uneven handles or smooth water flow in the later stage.

5. Better Alternatives to 3 Handle Bathtub and Shower Faucet
In addition to keeping the original 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet structure, you can also consider other more modern solutions depending on your budget and household needs.
If you prefer to maintain the original system and just replace it with new components of the same specification, this approach is suitable for situations with a limited budget or renting out a house. The installation is relatively simple, but the water temperature control is still rather traditional.
For families who wish to enhance the aesthetics and convenience of their bathrooms, a single-handle mixed water system is a good choice. It controls water temperature and flow through a handle, making it more intuitive to use and suitable for users who pursue a modern style. However, during installation, it might be necessary to cover the original holes or make certain modifications.
If you place more emphasis on the stability and safety of water temperature, such as when there are elderly people or children at home, you can consider a constant temperature system. This type of product can automatically adjust the water temperature to avoid the situation where the water temperature fluctuates between hot and cold. Although the installation is slightly more complicated and the cost is slightly higher, the comfort experience and safety guarantee it brings are also better.
Also, it is reminded that if you wish to upgrade to a single-handle system without making significant changes to the wall, you can use the dedicated conversion trim kit. It can cover the excess holes, be compatible with the new system at the same time, and reduce the construction difficulty.
6. Material and Brand Selection Tips
When choosing 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet, consider not only the price but also the material and after-sales service:
- Recommended materials: Ceramic valve core, 304 stainless steel or brass casting;
- Mainstream brands: ACE DECOR, Moen, Delta, Kohler, Pfister;
- Certification standard: It is more reassuring to choose products that comply with UPC or NSF certification.
- After-sales compatibility: Whether it supports the subsequent replacement of components such as handles and nozzles.
Meanwhile, many brands offer eco-friendly and water-saving accessories to help families control water consumption and respond to the current trend of "green families".
7. Maintenance Tips for Long-Term Use
Even the classic 3-handle bathtub and shower faucet structure can last for more than 10 years if properly maintained:
- Check whether the water pressure and flow rate are normal every six months.
- Replace the sealing rings and gaskets regularly to avoid dripping water.
- Keep dry when not in use to prevent rust.
If conditions permit, temperature limiters or check valves can be installed to enhance comfort and safety.

Conclusion
3 handle bathtub and shower faucet, though it has a long history, is not lacking in practical value. Especially for users who prefer a retro style and do not wish to make major changes to the pipeline, it remains a stable and reliable solution.
Of course, if you want a better temperature control experience, a more streamlined appearance or stronger security guarantees, you can also consider upgrading to a modern system. When choosing which one to pick, it is not only necessary to consider the budget, but also to match your usage habits and family needs.
Understanding life starts with knowing how to adjust the water temperature.
FAQ
Q1: Can 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet be fitted with heat protection?
Sure. Most three-handle systems can be equipped with temperature-limiting valves or water flow control devices to enhance the water safety of children and the elderly.
Q2: Can it be directly replaced with a single-handle system without removing the wall?
The dedicated trim cover kit can be used to cover the excess holes without damaging the wall surface, which is suitable for light renovation needs.
Q3: Are accessories still available for the old 3 handle bathtub and shower faucet?
Most brands offer support for models that have been around for many years, but it is recommended to keep the model label for easy reference in the future.
Q4: Does the three-handle system comply with modern water-saving standards?
Some models have supported water-saving devices, but their water efficiency is slightly lower compared to the constant temperature system. It can be optimized by replacing accessories such as nozzles.
Q5: Is it suitable for use in rental houses?
It is suitable, has a simple structure, is easy to maintain and has low repair costs. It is one of the preferred configurations for many landlords.
Related Articles:
5 Best Bathtub Shower Faucet Combos Reviewed
Bathtub Faucet Handle Stripping Trouble? Try These Productivity Tools and Tricks!
Do You Need a New Bathtub and Shower Faucet? Take This 60-Second Test