Do you sometimes feel attracted to something suddenly, without warning? It's like when you look at bathroom designs on Pinterest, and you get a flash of inspiration, and then you're stuck with choices that are more complicated than you thought. It's like deciding between shower base or tile… two perfectly good options, right? Which one will really save you money and also give you less to worry about? I've been in a similar situation before, faced with a bunch of options and not knowing which one is the best deal. Today, I want to help you make a decision through a simple comparison that I hope you won't regret.
Let's be honest, the bathroom is not just that little neglected corner of the house, it's a place you use every day - whether it's a quick shower in the morning or a hot bath to relax in the evening. If your bathroom is designed to look like a nice dressing room, it's even harder to ignore. Because of this, choosing a shower unit is important. But being faced with a variety of choices can be a bit of a struggle: do you prefer a clean and sleek shower base, or a classic and durable tile style? Either way, let’s dig into the pros and cons and see which one really saves you both cash and mental energy.
The Case for Shower Bases
Let's start with an easy option - a shower base. If you want a complete solution that saves time and is easy to install, a shower base may be a good fit for you. It's really just a pre-engineered, integral unit that fits right into the shower space. While some people may think they're choosing a shower base to save money, I think it's not only frugal, it's also very practical, especially for those who want a quick installation that's fully functional. Plus, shower bases are usually cheaper too.
Pro: Installation is a Breeze
One of the best things about the shower base is how easy it is to install. In most cases, you don't need to be particularly good at DIY to get it done. Whether you ask a professional to install it or do it yourself, it can usually be completed in a day or two, while tile laying can take several days or even weeks. The whole thing just clicks into place. The shower base is like an oversized jigsaw puzzle that fits snugly into your shower space. No grout lines to worry about. No waiting for anything to cure. It’s instant satisfaction.
Pro: Easy to Clean
If you've ever taken the time to scrub dirt and mold out of a tile crevice (and we all know how easy it is to get mold there), you'll love the simple design of the shower base. It has no crevices or grooves, so there's no place for dirt, soap scum, or water to accumulate, making it especially easy to clean. A simple wipe down and it's clean, just as hassle-free as using a smooth piece of tabletop.
Pro: Cost-Effective
Let's be honest, the expense of redoing a bathroom can easily become prohibitive. Shower bases are usually cheaper than tiling, especially if you want that upscale subway tile or an intricate design that would cost more to tile. For a basic setup, you can snag a solid base for a reasonable price, and you won’t need to fork out a ton for labor either. Shower bases use less material, are less of a hassle to install, and cost less money. With so many benefits, who wouldn't love it?
Con: Limited Design Options
While shower bases are practical, they do have some design limitations. Most bases come in standard sizes and shapes—square or rectangular. Although the shower base is available in a wide range of materials, such as acrylic, fiberglass or stone or whatever, to be honest, its design style is really a bit limited, and it's mainly a practical route. If you have a dream of a high end customized, super stunning shower in your mind, then the shower base might seem a little ...... well, too plain and not powerful enough.
The Tile Life: A Classic Choice
Tile is actually a very design space material. You can make a difference by choosing different colors, matching or designing unique patterns, or opting for a minimalist, sleek style, all of which can make a difference. So, it is a very flexible choice that allows you to play freely. However, it also requires more attention and maintenance from you. In short, ceramic tiles give you the freedom to design, but they also require more care and maintenance.
Pro: Endless Design Options
Here’s where tile gets really exciting. You can choose from a variety of styles, such as classic subway tiles, bold mosaics, or modern hexagons, herringbone and the like. Tiles can be completely according to your own ideas, to create a unique bathroom style. Color, size, texture can be selected according to your preferences, and don't forget the choice of sewing, although it seems unimportant, but in fact, it will affect the overall effect.
Pro: Durability
Tile is a very durable shower material that can last for years, even decades, as long as it is properly installed. Because it does not crack or deform as easily as some other materials, it can withstand frequent use and is quite reliable. Tile resists water and heat, and good quality tile is more durable than other shower base materials.
Cons: Requires Frequent Repairs & Maintenance
Tiles do look great, but keeping them looking great actually requires quite a bit of maintenance. Tile crevices (seams) can easily accumulate soap stains, mold, and other bathroom filth. If you don't like cleaning your shower once a week, tiling can be a bit of a hassle. Even if you clean carefully, gaps always need extra scrubbing. Moreover, laying tile itself also requires time and effort, and it is definitely not a matter of one or two days.
Con: Higher Initial Cost and Longer Installation
If you choose a high-end material like marble or a custom design, the upfront cost of tile can be higher, although it's usually quite durable. Besides, tiling actually takes time. Depending on the size of the shower and the complexity of the design, it can take days or even weeks to fix. You also have to consider the time it takes to cut the tile, the possible loss during laying, and the time it takes for the grout to dry. If time is tight or you don't want to waste too much material, tile may not be the best choice.
So, What Material Should You Choose In The End?
Now that the pros and cons are out of the way, it's time to consider which option is better for you.
Choose a Shower Base If…
- You're on a small budget.
- You don't want to spend too much time and energy on complicated things.
- You don't plan to live here very long, that is, you don't plan to treat this house as a long-term investment.
- You don't like cleaning, or you wish things didn't take too much care of.
- You’re okay with a more utilitarian look.
Choose Tile If…
- You're willing to spend time and money on an option that will last a long time.
- You want a unique and high-end look.
- You plan to live in the home for a few years and want to improve its resale value by renovating it.
- You don't mind taking the time to maintain and clean it.
- You love design and want to create a bathroom that will make people's eyes shine.
Ultimately, it comes down to what you value most. Are you after ease and practicality? Go with a shower base. Do you want a look that's both high end and a bit gaudy and sophisticated? Tile might just be your best friend. Remember that the bathroom belongs to you and the final decision should be made based on your needs and doesn't need to be overly complicated. As long as you've done your homework and know what you want, you've done well to get here.
Tell me, would you choose a practical shower base, or would you like to try a tile design? I’m always curious about what other people choose for their bathroom renos!
FAQS
What is the difference between shower base and tile in terms of non-slip?
The shower base is usually designed to be non-slip, such as with a textured surface or made of non-slip material, to prevent slipping more effectively. The tile depends on the surface texture and the type of tile, the non-slip tile effect is better, but if it is smooth tile, it is easy to slip.
After laying the tile, how long do I have to wait to use it?
Tiles generally take a few days to lay, and after installation, the adhesive and sealant need to wait 24 to 48 hours to dry. Therefore, it is usually necessary to wait 2 to 3 days before you can use the shower normally.
What is the difference in water resistance between shower bases and tile?
Shower bases are more water resistant overall due to their integrated design and stronger seal. Tile is inherently water resistant, but is slightly less waterproof as water may penetrate if the joints are not treated properly.
Related Articles
If you're in need of more bathroom design inspiration, or want other home improvement advice, check out these related articles. It's full of practical advice and design inspiration to help you create your ideal space!
